Election results and lessons

The success of Sinn Féin in the Irish general election has raised the question of Irish re-unification.

Political spin

The post-election use of results in order to reinterpret the campaign is a feature of political spin that needs to be identified and called out for what it is.

Let me illustrate it with the SNP and the 2019 UK General Election. Ten minutes to 10 p.m. on 12 Dec 2019, the SNP told voters to ‘Vote SNP to stop Brexit’.

Ten minutes after 10 p.m., when the exit poll suggested an SNP landslide, the SNP changed its message to “Scotland has voted for Independence”. This was the message of Ian Bradford MP in his victory speech, the leader of the SNP group at Westminster, following a similar message by Drew Hendry’s victory in the neighbouring constituency in the Scottish Highlands.

They justified this changed message by pointing to the failed Scottish Tory campaign message of ‘Stop IndyRef2’. However, everyone knows that the Election was about Brexit and the result of the election showed that a majority of Scottish voters voted for parties opposed to Scottish separation from the UK. Such is the nature of political spin.

The lies so prevalent in public and political debate requires a Christian Voice.

Sinn Féin

Sinn Féin fought the Irish election primarily on the housing shortage in Ireland, but now that it has done so well in the polls the Sinn Féin leader, Mary Lou McDonald, is emphasing its promise for an Irish unity poll within 5 years, and McDonald in the post-election discussion has already said that the UK and Northern Ireland must prepare for constitutional change.

Meanwhile a Belfast Telegraph columnist has played the Nazi card.

Northern Ireland
On the same day, Boris Johnson is considering a bridge from Scotland to Northern Ireland to level up the two economies. He indicated his support for this idea in a recent meeting with the public. He has shown himself open to grandiose ideas, but what if the UK pays for a bridge that facilitates Scotland separating from England and joining a re-united Ireland as members of the EU, surrounding England with EU member-states?

Update:

13 Feb 2020: BBC Question Time: “Is a bridge to Ireland a bridge too far?” The SNP Joanna Cherry MP rejoiced in the thought that re-united Ireland, united by a bridge with independent Scotland in the EU would allow Irish goods to go to Europe through Scotland and expand Leith and east Scotland ports. So, “is it a bridge too far?” Yes, in unstable times. Meanwhile, the SNP can get on with improving infrastructure within Scotland and build a bridge over the stormy Minch to the Outer Hebrides. If Ireland re-unites, that is soon enough for a re-united Ireland to pay for a joint venture, including clearing up the munitions dump of more than a million tons of weapons from WWII dumped in Beaufort’s Dyke. And why was there no question about former SNP Derek Mackay? Why did Question Time in Dundee not have a Scottish Tory MSP or MP on the panel, or better still, why not ask a question about it?

14 Feb 2020: Nigel Farage’s summary on Boris’ bridge.

One thought on “Election results and lessons

  1. Mr Colin Mansfield

    Hi Donald,
    We are a few months ahead of Donald Tusk’s last EU statement, where he welcomed the thought of Scotland breaking away to “re-join” the EU in the future. Also Eire’s PM a few months further back intimated that the “best solution” over the Irish border would be a United Ireland, all within the EU of course.
    >
    The worst scenario for the UK post-Brexit, would be for England & Wales to be surrounded by the EU and its new “vassal states.” We may well be building our own entrapment by starting with a bridge over the Irish Sea (the EU Parliament never considered funding one). Our hope is that the EU’s new move to absorb the remaining Balkan states, including Serbia & Kosovo, would keep them busy for decades within their own orbit, all under German tutelage.
    >
    Let us not forget that Eire was forced to become a neutral country during WW2, after overtures from the Nazis were discovered. Dublin’s book of condolences for Adolf Hitler’s death, must rankle with modern Irish historians.
    >
    Scotland would also like to relive its old histories and breakaway from England no matter what the cost to itself,
    Colin.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.